Television is home to countless shows that come and go, with some slipping under the radar despite their brilliance. While big-budget hits and trending series often get all the attention, there are numerous most underrated TV shows that deserve far more recognition. These hidden gems offer everything from deep storytelling and complex characters to unique concepts and thought-provoking themes. Let’s dive into some of the most underrated TV shows that have flown under the radar.
20 Most Underrated TV Shows
Before we get into the list of the most underrated TV shows, it’s important to understand why some shows don’t get the recognition they deserve. Many of these shows suffer from poor timing, limited promotion, or competition from more popular series. Whether you’re a fan of deep psychological dramas, quirky comedies, or unique sci-fi adventures, there’s something here for everyone.
1. The Leftovers (2014-2017)
One of the most emotionally intense and complex dramas in recent years, The Leftovers often gets overshadowed by its contemporaries. Set in a world where 2% of the population mysteriously vanishes without a trace, the show explores themes of grief, loss, and the search for meaning in an uncertain world. While it’s often categorized as a post-apocalyptic show, it’s much more about the human experience and how people cope with the unexplainable.
With stunning performances by Justin Theroux, Carrie Coon, and Ann Dowd, The Leftovers offers deep character studies that are emotionally raw and unsettling. Its second and third seasons, in particular, elevate the show into one of the most compelling narratives about the human condition, this show is often listed among the most underrated TV shows of all time.
2. Terriers (2010)
Despite critical acclaim, Terriers was canceled after just one season, largely because of its limited viewership. The show centers around Hank Dolworth (Donal Logue), a former cop turned private investigator, and his partner Britt Pollack (Michael Raymond-James), as they navigate the seedy underbelly of their small California town. It’s a gritty, dark comedy with moments of heart and incredible character development.
The show blends the genres of noir detective stories and dramedy, with sharp writing and fantastic performances from the lead cast. If you’re looking for a compelling yet underappreciated gem, Terriers is a must-watch.
3. Hannibal (2013-2015)
While Hannibal gained some critical praise for its aesthetic and psychological depth, it never reached the mainstream heights it deserved. This psychological horror-thriller, based on the Thomas Harris novels, delves into the minds of the iconic characters Dr. Hannibal Lecter (Mads Mikkelsen) and Will Graham (Hugh Dancy), exploring the complexities of their relationship as they engage in a chilling game of cat-and-mouse.
With a gorgeous visual style, a hauntingly poetic script, and stellar performances, Hannibal stands out as a unique show that balances gore with intellectual depth. Hannibal remains one of the underrated TV series that doesn’t get the love it deserves.
4. The Expanse (2015-2021)
Often hailed as one of the best sci-fi shows in recent years, The Expanse didn’t get nearly as much attention as other genre-defining series like Game of Thrones. Set in a future where humanity has colonized the solar system, the show blends politics, space exploration, and social commentary in a way few sci-fi shows manage.
With its multi-layered narrative, a deep focus on characters, and brilliant world-building, The Expanse is an intelligent space opera that offers more than just the typical thrills of space adventures. The show’s rich storytelling makes it a standout for any sci-fi lover. It might be one of the best underrated TV series on Netflix.
5. Party Down (2009-2010)
Party Down is a workplace comedy series that features a group of eccentric catering staff working at various events in Los Angeles. The show stars Adam Scott, Ken Marino, and Lizzy Caplan, and blends witty humor with biting commentary on the entertainment industry. Though it had a short run, Party Down has garnered a loyal cult following over the years.
What sets it apart from other workplace comedies is its sharp writing and its ability to capture the struggles of dreamers trying to make it in Hollywood. The chemistry between the cast and the quirky characters they play adds an extra layer of charm to the series. If you’re into ensemble-based humor, this is one of the underrated TV shows to binge.
6. The Knick (2014-2015)
This period medical drama set in the early 20th century is a visually stunning and morally complex show that explores the birth of modern medicine. Set in New York City, The Knick follows Dr. John Thackery (Clive Owen), a brilliant but deeply flawed surgeon, as he navigates the challenges of his profession, addiction, and his own personal demons.
The show’s gritty portrayal of medical advancements during that era is fascinating, and its cinematic style makes it feel like a high-quality film rather than a standard TV show. Though it never garnered the audience it deserved, The Knick is a masterpiece in terms of both writing and performances. If you’re into historical drama with a dark twist, this is an underrated TV series to watch.
7. Better Off Ted (2009-2010)
If you enjoy witty, fast-paced workplace comedies with a twist of absurdity, Better Off Ted is an underappreciated gem. Set in a fictional high-tech company, the show follows Ted Crisp (Jay Harrington), an optimistic but somewhat clueless head of R&D, and the bizarre experiments his team creates.
With its quirky humor and smart commentary on corporate culture and technology, Better Off Ted is often overlooked despite having a dedicated fanbase. It’s the perfect show for fans of offbeat humor and a lighthearted take on corporate life. Better Off Ted is definitely an underrated TV series worth checking out.
8. The Terror (2018-2019)
This historical horror anthology series is based on the ill-fated voyage of the British Royal Navy’s HMS Terror and HMS Erebus in the mid-19th century. The show combines a true story of a doomed expedition with supernatural horror, offering a chilling and atmospheric experience.
The first season is particularly captivating, offering a slow burn of tension and suspense, paired with stunning cinematography and strong performances. Despite its critical acclaim, The Terror never gained the audience it deserved, making it one of the most underrated shows in recent years. It is one of the most underrated TV shows to watch.
9. The Mindy Project (2012-2017)
While The Mindy Project has gained a certain level of popularity, it remains vastly underrated in terms of its impact on comedy. Created by and starring Mindy Kaling, the show follows Dr. Mindy Lahiri, an OB/GYN with a complex love life and high ambitions.
Though some dismissed it as a typical rom-com, The Mindy Project broke boundaries by embracing diverse characters and exploring relationships in an unconventional way. Its quirky humor and emotional depth make it a standout in the rom-com genre.
10. Pushing Daisies (2007-2009)
Pushing Daisies is a whimsical and visually stunning series that combines romance, mystery, and fantasy. It follows Ned (Lee Pace), a pie-maker with the ability to bring people back to life—though only for a minute, or they’ll die again permanently.
The show is incredibly unique with its quirky premise, colorful visuals, and mix of dark humor and lighthearted romance. Despite its cancellation after just two seasons, Pushing Daisies remains a cult classic and a perfect example of how TV can be both bizarre and heartwarming at the same time. Pushing Daisies is a prime example of most underrated TV shows of all time.
11- The Fall (2013-2016)
The Fall is a psychological crime drama set in Belfast, focusing on the cat-and-mouse game between Detective Stella Gibson (Gillian Anderson) and serial killer Paul Spector (Jamie Dornan). The series stands out for its chilling portrayal of a cold, calculating killer, along with Gibson’s clinical, methodical investigation.
The slow-building suspense, chilling tension, and exceptional performances from Anderson and Dornan make The Fall a hidden gem for crime-thriller lovers. Its dark, atmospheric tone and insightful commentary on the psychology of both the killer and the investigator make it a compelling watch that deserved more attention.
12- The IT Crowd (2006-2013)
This British sitcom takes place in the basement of a corporation, where the hapless staff of the IT department — Moss (Richard Ayoade), Roy (Chris O’Dowd), and Jen (Katherine Parkinson) — deal with all sorts of bizarre workplace problems. The show is full of witty, offbeat humor, memorable one-liners, and oddball characters that make it a cult classic.
The IT Crowd touches on the absurdity of office culture and geeky tech life with a comedic twist. Though it garnered a passionate following, it never reached the mainstream popularity it truly deserved, especially considering how well it holds up as an office comedy.
13- The Exorcist (2016-2017)
A chilling TV adaptation of the legendary 1973 horror film, The Exorcist takes a modern approach to the terrifying story of possession. The series follows two priests, Father Tomas Ortega (Alfonso Herrera) and Father Marcus Keane (Ben Daniels), as they confront an escalating series of supernatural events.
With a focus on psychological terror and gripping storytelling, the show explores themes of faith, evil, and the complexities of human nature. Despite strong performances and an eerie atmosphere, the series failed to gain widespread attention, leaving it as an underrated horror gem.
14- Rectify (2013-2016)
Rectify follows the emotional journey of Daniel Holden (Aden Young), a man released from death row after spending 19 years in prison for a crime he may not have committed. The show explores the impact of this release on Daniel and his family, delving into themes of redemption, guilt, and the slow process of reintegration into society.
The storytelling is methodical, emphasizing character development and quiet moments of introspection. This slow-burn drama is a deeply moving exploration of trauma and justice. Though critically acclaimed, it remains a hidden gem for viewers seeking character-driven stories.
15- Halt and Catch Fire (2014-2017)
Set against the backdrop of the early days of the personal computing revolution in the 1980s and ’90s, Halt and Catch Fire focuses on a group of innovators attempting to build the next big thing in technology. Led by Joe MacMillan (Lee Pace), a charismatic but often morally ambiguous entrepreneur, and Gordon Clark (Scoot McNairy), a brilliant but troubled engineer, the show examines the personal and professional challenges they face.
Halt and Catch Fire explores the intersection of human ambition and technological advancement, but it was overshadowed by more mainstream shows. The series’ poignant character arcs and emotional depth make it one of the most underappreciated TV dramas.
16- The Good Place (2016-2020)
A fresh take on the afterlife, The Good Place stars Kristen Bell as Eleanor Shellstrop, a woman who finds herself in the afterlife’s “Good Place” but soon realizes she doesn’t belong there. The series cleverly combines humor with deep philosophical questions about morality, ethics, and personal growth.
Through its witty writing, delightful characters, and surprising twists, The Good Place challenges viewers to rethink what it means to be good, making it a standout show. Despite being widely loved by fans and critics, it did not have the same cultural impact as other sitcoms of its time, making it an underrated series to explore.
17- Banshee (2013-2016)
Banshee is a gritty, fast-paced crime drama set in the small town of Banshee, Pennsylvania. The story follows an ex-con (Antony Starr) who assumes the identity of the town’s murdered sheriff. While trying to rebuild his criminal empire, he becomes entangled with a series of dangerous events, including gang wars, betrayal, and personal conflicts.
Banshee is known for its brutal action scenes, intense drama, and complex characters. Though critically acclaimed for its bold storytelling, it never reached the audience it deserved, remaining an underrated show for lovers of high-octane crime dramas.
18- The Newsroom (2012-2014)
Created by Aaron Sorkin, The Newsroom is a drama set in a fictional cable news network. It follows news anchor Will McAvoy (Jeff Daniels) and his team as they navigate the cutthroat world of broadcast journalism. The series is known for its sharp dialogue, fast-paced writing, and its unapologetic stance on the role of media in shaping public opinion.
Despite its critical praise, particularly for Daniels’ award-winning performance, The Newsroom never gained the widespread popularity it deserved. Its timely exploration of news media and its ethical dilemmas make it a must-watch for TV drama fans.
19- Lodge 49 (2018-2019)
Lodge 49 is an eccentric, thoughtful dramedy that blends mystery and surrealism. The show follows Sean “Dud” Dudley (Wyatt Russell), a disillusioned former surfer who joins a fraternal lodge in Long Beach. As he embarks on a quest to find meaning and purpose, the show delves into themes of friendship, self-discovery, and the search for a greater sense of belonging.
With a quirky charm and slow-burn narrative, Lodge 49 captivated its small but devoted audience. Unfortunately, it was canceled too soon, leaving it as an underrated gem for those who appreciate unconventional storytelling.
20- Kingdom (2014-2017)
Set in the world of mixed martial arts (MMA), Kingdom revolves around the Kulina family and their gym, where father Alvey (Frank Grillo) and his sons try to navigate personal and professional conflicts in the high-stakes world of MMA fighting.
The series highlights the physical, emotional, and psychological toll that the sport takes on its fighters, exploring themes of family, loyalty, and redemption. With strong performances, particularly from Grillo, Kingdom became an underrated favorite among MMA fans and drama lovers alike. Despite being critically praised, it was largely overlooked by mainstream audiences.
Why These Shows Are Worth Your Time
If you are looking for underrated TV series to watch of all time, these shows are more than worth your time. While they may have slipped under the radar, they each offer something unique in terms of storytelling, characters, and overall quality. Whether you’re in the mood for something quirky, dark, or thought-provoking, these underrated gems won’t disappoint.
FAQs
Conclusion: Why You Should Watch These Most Underrated TV Shows
Television is filled with hidden gems that never quite get the attention they deserve. From deeply philosophical dramas like The Leftovers to offbeat comedies like Better Off Ted, there’s something for every kind of viewer. While the popular shows dominate the charts, these most underrated TV shows continue to captivate audiences with their storytelling, unique premises, and unforgettable characters.
If you haven’t yet seen these shows, now is the time to discover these hidden treasures that are sure to leave an impression.
For more recommendations, check out:
- Top sci-fi TV shows that will take you on thrilling adventures across time and space.
- Best crime series for those who love mysteries, twists, and gripping drama.
Leave a Reply